Skip navigation
867 Views 10 Replies Latest reply: Feb 11, 2012 3:10 PM by Mlynch74d3 RSS
Mlynch74d3 Just Startin' 12 posts since
Dec 24, 2011
Currently Being Moderated

Feb 7, 2012 11:44 PM

Best Line6 Product For Home Recording ONLY

Hey everyone,

 

I basically have 2 questions:

 

1 - What line 6 product is best for home recording strictly?  I won't be using it to perform live, so home recording is all I care about here.  Would it be the Podxt, Pod X3, PodHD500, Pod Farm, etc?

 

What is best for home recording in terms of sound quality?  I currently own the POD HD500, and while I'm sure it's great, I'm starting to wonder if it has a LOT of features that are geared towards the live performer, which I don't need.  Also, I've noticed that there really aren't very many good patches for it on the custom tone section of the website, to be honest.

 

When I do a search for patches for the pod farm, pod x3 or xt, on the other hand, there are tons of very highly rated custom patches.  Since I'm not adept at creating my own tones, I'd really like to download high quality custom patches while I learn how to create my own.  This is another reason I'm leaning towards something other than the POD HD 500.

 

So for home recording strictly, what would you recommend?

 

2 - Also, what is this POD Farm, and what line 6 product can I use it with?  Can it be used with the POD HD500?  It doesn't seem like it from what I can tell.  If I get a POD X3 or XT, can I use POD Farm?  It seems to have a lot of great custom patches, and I've seen a few youtube videos where the pod farm sounded amazing.

 

I'm sure I sound pretty clueless, but that's because I am.  I'm new to Line6, and I really don't know much about the different products, but I'd like to know your opinions on what the best POD is for home recording. 

 

Thanks a lot

  • chimp_spanner Just Startin' 336 posts since
    Nov 7, 2008
    Currently Being Moderated
    Feb 8, 2012 2:30 AM (in response to Mlynch74d3)
    Re: Best Line6 Product For Home Recording ONLY

    To be totally honest, seeing how the HD500 is currently their flagship processor (in terms of DSP power alongside the HD and HD Pro) I would stick with it. For home recording, flexibility in your FX chain is going to be really important. I also wouldn't change products purely on the basis of what's available on Custom Tone! While I'm sure it's a great resource for some, there's no substitute for just doing it yourself.

     

    Plus, just because you don't need it for live purposes (yet!) doesn't mean you won't need foot control. You could buy an X3 but then still need to buy an FBV if you want to record things like Wah, Whammy FX, or other things. I went through a crazy sequence of products and wasted a lot of money buying/selling various POD Lives, beans, FBV's etc. before I finally came to realise that it's best to have all my options in one package just in case.

     

    Also I'm really indecisive haha.

     

    Anyway just my opinion. But with the 2.0 firmware coming out soon (including an Ampeg bass model and a mic pre-amp modeller) the HD is going to become a way more capable piece of kit for people looking for all in one recording solutions.

     

    I don't doubt that there will be a POD Farm HD in the future. But even if not, going back to the X series of modelling would feel like a step backwards for you once you've played the HD.

    • jimsreynolds Power User 2,227 posts since
      Jun 27, 43450
      Currently Being Moderated
      Feb 8, 2012 4:18 AM (in response to chimp_spanner)
      Re: Best Line6 Product For Home Recording ONLY

      +1 on all of Chimp_spanner.  The only reasons I can see for trading away from the HD500 is

       

      • HD Bean has a smaller form factor if desk space is at a premium but has less inputs and outputs which can certainly be an issue.
      • Pro is rackable and a few more inputs and outputs but has no additional tone processing or functionality. 

       

      Neither has the expression pedal.

       

      With the XT it is a question of quantity over quality.  The HD nails the amp modelling significantly better than the XT but the XT has more amps to play with ... today.   If diversity is essential to what you do (or there is a very specific tone that the XT does that you want) then maybe there is benefit in the XT but IMHO you are better off with the higher quality tones on the HD. 

       

      A final point:  based on what I read,  the XT has some routing tricks that the HD does not and vice versa in terms of getting wet and dry tones recorded. That may be relevant

      • silverhead Expert Line 6 User 9,592 posts since
        Apr 1, 2009
        Currently Being Moderated
        Feb 8, 2012 1:21 PM (in response to Mlynch74d3)
        Re: Best Line6 Product For Home Recording ONLY

        Here are a couple of good resources, both form Line 6 forum users: MerlinFL and meambobbo:

        http://line6.com/support/thread/77774

        http://line6.com/support/thread/71651?tstart=0  and http://foobazaar.com/podhd/toneGuide/index.html

         

        Mlynch74d3 wrote:

         

        .... There is a certain appeal in downloading real good patches that nail the tone I'm looking for with no work involved,...

        Yes, that's a nice dream - but the reality is that there are so many other factors that affect the final tone. Each patch loaded up to Cutomtone was created in a specific environment: a certain guitar with specific pickups and tone/volume settings, a certain amp or pair of speakers, or headphones, etc...... All of these things contribute to the final sound. And what may have sounded great in the environment where it was created will not sound anything like that in the environment of the preson who downloads the tone and uses it with different equipment. There is almost always a need to tweak the tone substantially in your own environment. And the best way to understand how they should be tweaked is to become familiar with creating your own tones. That really is the best way to start. Customtone will become more valuable to you after you understand how your own equipment works best with the Pod HD.

         

        EDIT: Here's another useful resource:

        http://line6.com/support/docs/DOC-2525

More Like This

  • Retrieving data ...

Bookmarked By (0)

Legend

  • Correct Answers - 5 points
  • Helpful Answers - 3 points