Skip navigation
1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 Previous Next 16620 Views 139 Replies Latest reply: Feb 5, 2013 4:19 AM by RonMarton RSS Go to original post
  • kisslorand Just Startin' 31 posts since
    Sep 23, 2009
    Currently Being Moderated
    90. Oct 15, 2012 11:22 PM (in response to dboomer)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

       I have this Relay G50 from 2010. From the first day I was using it attached to my pants. I think I used it more than 1000 hours without any issue at all. I always used low power setting, even on stage (some of them big ones). So if it worked 2 years flawlessly, why is it suddenly a problem using it the way I did 2 years without any problems? The problems appeared gradually. At first small drop-outs followed by a quick resync. Those small drop-outs happened once/twice a month. Than they started to appear more often. These drop-outs occured in different locations. 3 months back the dropout happened without an auto resync. I had to reset both units (transmitter/receiver). Since than dropouts are never followed by an auto resync. I am an engineer in electronics, I am used to behaviours of electronic devices. Also I am way over 30years, I have seen enough guitar gear. From my experience it is a clear sign of a HW failure when the faults happening more often and more severe regardless of the situations. BTW, no WiFi is present at our actual rehearsal room. I remember using my G50 at a rehearsal room for 2 years where right there was a WiFi router, there was naver any problem. I even used my G50 at home (when it worked), where the receiver was 50cm from my WiFi router, never had any problems (Relay on channel 1, router on channel 9).

      I am using my G50 within a range of 1-3 meters in our rehearsal room, I recall that it was mentioned that in very small range it is not adviced to use on high power. Anyway I did try that also, same thing, dropouts without any resync, signal leds off (not even the red led on). I think someone mentioned G50 doesn't like iPhones, on mine the WiFi is always off, it rests far from my G50 system.

       Is it a possibility that Thomann Germany service is not really qualified repairing this unit?

  • dboomer Line 6 Support 1,997 posts since
    Oct 13, 2008
    Currently Being Moderated
    91. Oct 16, 2012 11:41 AM (in response to kisslorand)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    I guess if you are convinced the problem is hardware failure then you should find alternative service station.  Click on contact us link at bottom of page.

     

    Alternatively you could flash the unit with newer firmware.  It does require access to a v75 as the interface.

     

    I'm still not certain that you have ruled out local interference.  I would still like to hear the results of running on high power and at a different venue.  With the transmitter turned off do you see red LEDs on any/all channels?

  • kisslorand Just Startin' 31 posts since
    Sep 23, 2009
    Currently Being Moderated
    92. Oct 17, 2012 9:54 PM (in response to dboomer)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    I cannot flash it because the one I have is one of the very first units. Thomann Germany is asking me 50EUR (~65USD) for firmware upgrade.

    About the LEDs, please check my post from September the 11th. The unit is still at Thomann, I am thinking to buy a new one because the resolving of this issue is going nowhere.

    Today I will make a scan of the recievable WiFi networks and I will try to borrow a 2.4GHz WiFi spectrum analyzer.

     

    P.S.: Do you think a V75 would be more suitable for my needs? Is it less prone to dropouts? Or maybe G55...

     

    Later edit: I just checked WiFi activity in our rehearsal room, the highest signal was -82dBm. This was at 12:30 PM, a busy period of the day.

  • dboomer Line 6 Support 1,997 posts since
    Oct 13, 2008
    Currently Being Moderated
    93. Oct 18, 2012 9:48 AM (in response to kisslorand)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    The advantage that a V75/55 or G90 would give you would be the ability to add paddle antennas which would add to reliability. Also their is a small range improvement with them.  Aside from that all units should be nearly identical in performance if they were all operating in similar conditions

  • adamdegraff Just Startin' 14 posts since
    Nov 26, 2010
    Currently Being Moderated
    94. Oct 18, 2012 10:00 AM (in response to dboomer)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    dboomer,

    can you walk us through the firmware update? I have 6 G50s, 2 G90's, and 4XDV-70s that we use in various configurations. We think the line6 digital wireless is great, but we do get regular drop outs. After using them for 3 years now, I can say that they are by far the best option, but they aren't perfect. Maybe this firmware update will smooth out the wrinkles? We don't own any of the xd75s though. How can we go about getting the necessary firmware? Am I to understand that we'd be updating the beltpacks of the 50/90/70 with the receiver of the 75?  Is there any chance that this update will fry our current gear?

     

    Thanks,

     

    Adam

  • kisslorand Just Startin' 31 posts since
    Sep 23, 2009
    Currently Being Moderated
    95. Oct 18, 2012 11:31 AM (in response to dboomer)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    What about the LEDs beeing off? What about the fee Thomann is asking for FW upgrade, is it legit? What about the -82dBm signal?

    Can you please explain if the unit is not broken what can cause the dropout and the need to power them off and on to get the signal back? If that something is causing dropout than why is the unit resyncing after a power off/on cycle?

  • dboomer Line 6 Support 1,997 posts since
    Oct 13, 2008
    Currently Being Moderated
    96. Oct 18, 2012 10:41 AM (in response to adamdegraff)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    The basic update method is here ...  http://line6.com/support/docs/DOC-2707

     

    You MUST have access to a V75 becasue it has a USB port that is necessary so it can act as an interface.  There have been a number of incremental improvements over the years and they are all wrapped up in the V2.x update.  Hard to say if you will see any improvement to dropouts because they are usually caused by local conditions, but it couldn't hurt.  I have never experienced it "frying" any gear.

  • dboomer Line 6 Support 1,997 posts since
    Oct 13, 2008
    Currently Being Moderated
    97. Oct 18, 2012 10:50 AM (in response to kisslorand)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    I'm sorry ... I was not understanding that what you are experiencing is a power on/off cycle.  If that's the case I would try to rule out a problem with battery size (this happens with rechargables frequently) or that the battery terminals have become damaged or bent.

     

    It is also possible that certain kinds of interference (dropouts) can cause the units to re-sync and if that is the case there are some firmware improvements that could be beneficial in some cases.  As far as an upgrade fee, we also charge for that service in the US as it takes a certain amount of bench repair time and there are shipping fees involved.

     

    Its difficult to guess across the internet without having actual access to the gear.

  • gcdef Just Startin' 11 posts since
    Sep 5, 2008
    Currently Being Moderated
    98. Oct 18, 2012 10:53 AM (in response to dboomer)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    Don, that's not the case with these units.  All three of mine dropped out in places I play on a regular basis.  Places where other units don't experience any problems at all.  You're in denial here.  There really is a problem with these units and blaming it on local conditions instead of where the blame really belongs, isn't doing your customer base any favors at all.  I'm sure the majority of the units work properly, but you can't just shrug your shoulders and pass the buck to the environment with the ones that don't.  I wish I knew what it would take for you to pull your head out of the sand.

     

    With all the wireless units I've used, and with all the wireless units other people I've played with, I don't recall ever seeing a dropout, let alone dropouts ever few minutes that these products exhibit.

  • kisslorand Just Startin' 31 posts since
    Sep 23, 2009
    Currently Being Moderated
    99. Oct 18, 2012 11:16 AM (in response to dboomer)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    "If that's the case I would try to rule out a problem with battery size (this happens with rechargables frequently) or that the battery terminals have become damaged or bent."

    I have to power cycle the reciever also several times to get the units to sync. Sometimes 1 cycle is OK, sometimes up to ~10 is needed.

    Since the first time sync problem appeared I changed more than 40 batteries (never used rechargables). I use the exact same type of batteries from the beginning. 2 years they were the right size?

    I read/program PLCC, QFP, TQPF, SOP, PSOP, DIP processors, flash and eeprom memories almost on daily basis. I think I can spot a contact problem. Believe me or not, it's not the case, checked it already. If it was the case I would not see anything on the sender's display, right? Or if it is a very short problem of power supply on the sender, I should see the sender rebooting. Not the case, checked.

     

    I have to ask it again... Do you really think a -82dBm or lower signal can cause interference to the Relay G50? Does the LEDs beeing off telling you anything? They are telling me that no recievable signal is present at the selected channel or the reciever is unable to recieve a signal at that channel... or both. Am I wrong here?

     

    BTW, can I have the flash file so I can update the FW myself? Is the FW stored in MCU or Flash?

     

    OH!!! I forgot to tell you some very important thing!!! After the dropout occurs, all LEDs are going off and then the battery meter comes back showing the status of the batteries from the sender. How is this possible if the sender and receiver is not synced???

  • dboomer Line 6 Support 1,997 posts since
    Oct 13, 2008
    Currently Being Moderated
    100. Oct 18, 2012 11:34 AM (in response to kisslorand)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    No, I expect that a -82dBm level should not be a problem.

     

    As far as re-syncing cycles, there is some timing involved so if you do it too quickly then it is still possible that it could take a number of them.  What time period is this over?

     

    Seeing no activity on the receiver's LEDs could also indicate a problem with the receiver.  Did Thomann check both TX and Rx?

     

    Flashing the update is only possible through Line 6 Monkey.  We do not have any other method avaliable to protect proprietary code.

     

    The unanswered question is why did it appear to work correctly when on the test bench at Thomann?  What is different?  I suspect that when that question is answered then the problem can be corrected.

     

    We would be happy to check the system if you send it to us but short of that I just have to guess as to what is most likely going on.

  • kisslorand Just Startin' 31 posts since
    Sep 23, 2009
    Currently Being Moderated
    101. Oct 18, 2012 12:23 PM (in response to dboomer)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    I remember one time dropout occured we took a break and went out for a smoke. I left the units on, when we were back they were just as I left them, unsynced. This is the biggest time period I can recall. Of course I had to switch off and on the units.

    I still wonder how can you exlpain the reciver shows the battery status but signal strength LEDs ar off?

    Thomann has both the receiver and the sender, they told me they sent them to an authorized Line6 repair center. The response from this repair sender was: "As you can see on the forum these kind of problems are conditioned by the environment they are used in. Also on the forum you can see other kind of problems described. The system was tested here for a long period of time under praxis conditions, the problems were not confirmed."

    I told Thomann also that it can pass a week without any issue and the next rehearsal dropouts every 15-30 minutes. I doubt Thomann (or whoever else) tested as much as I did. I have 4 rehearsals a week, usually 2 hours/rehearsal. That's 8 hours of playing that can go by without any issue. I have dropout isses for 7 months now, I tested whatever tests I could come up with. Changed 220V connectors, changed power modes, changed channels, I saw dropouts with fresh batteries also, checked the power plug that goes into the reciever. BTW, all of our gear is powered trough a power stabilizer with servo motor. I keep my eyes on the output power, it is solid 220V regardless of the input voltage. I know it should not be an issue, the power source of the Line6 Relay G50 is a switching power supply.

     

    My unit is still under warranty, I am without it for a month now. If I send it to you it would take a very long time to make the roundtrip and get it repaired/replaced/whatever. This forces me to buy another unit even if I already own one, even if it is under warranty. I need the wireless system, that's why I bought it!

    I asked Thomann what if I buy another unit and it will work flawlessly "under the same circumstances". Guess what! No answer to that!

    You are the maker of the unit, Thoman is only a reseller, I am only an unhappy customer (even if I own several other Line6 products). Who's the only one that looses anything? I guess it's me. Why? Because I am little, law of the jungle.

     

    "The unanswered question is why did it appear to work correctly when on the test bench at Thomann?  What is different?  I suspect that when that question is answered then the problem can be corrected"

    The other question is why does it appear to work correctly for a week or so for me and than fails and than working again for a week and so on? Who's the one that has to answer to these questions? Line6, Thomann, me?

  • dboomer Line 6 Support 1,997 posts since
    Oct 13, 2008
    Currently Being Moderated
    102. Oct 18, 2012 7:15 PM (in response to kisslorand)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    The battery indication simply doesnt change because it doesn't update.

     

    The fact that it works sometimes and then some weeks it doesn't would seem to indicate that either the hardware has an intermittent problem or that the local conditions change.  This is also consistant with the fact that it worked well for a long time and then changed.  That would seem to rule out any firmware issues.  The newest firmware may be able to deal better with certain kinds of interference and quicker re-syncing but if we don't know what that is we wouldn't be able to speculate.

     

    Thomann of course can't make any guarantees to performance without being able to guarantee the local conditions.  Your -82 dBm measurement may change over time so you would really need to be making the measurement at the time you get the dropout to know if interference is a factor.

     

    As to why it works for a week or so and then fails again it points back to an intermittent hardware issue or to a change in local conditions.  It could also be a combination of both.  Again we would be happy to test and measure it but we would have to get it back to do that.

     

    I have one other question that could shed some light... are you getting normal battery life (6-8 hours) with new batteries?

  • kisslorand Just Startin' 31 posts since
    Sep 23, 2009
    Currently Being Moderated
    103. Oct 18, 2012 10:47 PM (in response to dboomer)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    "The battery indication simply doesnt change because it doesn't update." - sounds like a firmware bug. No signal but battery level is indicated... So I cannot trust the battery indicator at shows? Nice!

     

    "The fact that it works sometimes and then some weeks it doesn't would seem to indicate that either the hardware has an intermittent problem or that the local conditions change.  This is also consistant with the fact that it worked well for a long time and then changed.  That would seem to rule out any firmware issues."

    Are you telling me that for two years I never encountered bad local conditions wherever I went and for 7 months I encounter ONLY bad local conditions ??? Suddenly everyone has high power devices at 2.4GHz and they only power it on when I use my Relay G50? Can I be more unlucky than that?

    During those 7 months I made another test, I used the receiver  near my WiFi router. Right near the router I had signal strength problems (showing only 2 of 3 LEDs) but no dropouts, at 1~2 meters no signal problems, no dropouts. The signal is -22dBm at 50cm from the router and -30dBm at 1 meter. Both units were on channel 1 at the time of the tests. If it was not a bad environment for the Relay G50 than I cannot imagine what is! For me it is just a proof that your system is a good one but only when it works, when no HW failure or whatever else that might be the issue with my unit.

     

    "Again we would be happy to test and measure it but we would have to get it back to do that." Can you arrange that with Thomann or that specific authorized Line6 service they are referring to? Do I have to do that? I am afraid the expences and the time consumed to get to the USA and back not worth it. I have to mention again that my unit is still under warranty. Based on European laws I do not have to pay to send my unit for repair under warranty period.

     

    OK, I will order a new G50, I will have my questionable G50 back, I will make measurements during rehearsal. Should I also record a video of the issue while I play?

     

    How close can two recievers be? I am asking it because I want to record both of them. I am not sure I will be able to record my laptop's screen, the two receivers and still play the guitar. But hey, these days a musician has to be an engineer and a magician also!   Maybe I will learn to write my name on the carpet with my left foot in the same time too... LOL  ...or do the "moonwalk".

     

    I can go through five rehearsals with one set of batteries. This was from the beginning, it didn't change. I use Varta High Energy.

  • dboomer Line 6 Support 1,997 posts since
    Oct 13, 2008
    Currently Being Moderated
    104. Oct 19, 2012 10:16 AM (in response to kisslorand)
    Re: Relay G50 signal dropout

    The battery indicator is accurate to 10 minutes and it updates itself (assuming the transmitter is synced) every 800 ms.

     

    Video could help sort out the problem.  Just keep the antennas at least 5" away from each other.  While you are at it ... it could also prove useful to use the new TX with the old RX and visa versa.

1 ... 5 6 7 8 9 10 Previous Next

More Like This

  • Retrieving data ...

Bookmarked By (0)

Legend

  • Correct Answers - 5 points
  • Helpful Answers - 3 points