Skip navigation
5513 Views 10 Replies Latest reply: Jul 20, 2009 7:08 AM by cgtrox RSS
Hollow_Vessels Just Startin' 13 posts since
Nov 3, 2008
Currently Being Moderated

Jul 16, 2009 10:46 AM

Pod XTL sounds too digital when recording?

I bought the XTL in Nov 08 hoping that it will make my tone better and that I can start recording with a good tone. Today I've noticed that when recording it sounds fine (through my speaker) but when I listen to it through my computer speakers it sounds so digital and I dislike it very much. Is there some way to make it sounds less digital/more tube-like?

 

In case you're wondering which amp model i'm using, i'm using the Solo 100, and for stomp i'm using FX-Boost.

  • MerlinFL Iknowathingortwo 1,524 posts since
    Jul 17, 2007
    Currently Being Moderated
    Jul 16, 2009 11:30 AM (in response to Hollow_Vessels)
    Re: Pod XTL sounds too digital when recording?

    I'm not familiar intimately with your specific product, but I have to believe that all the amp models are the same.  I've recorded many guitar tracks and unless I tell someone what I used, they never guess it was all solid state ceertaily never guess a Line 6 Vetta plugged directly into the board.

     

    First question I have for you is have you given any thought that it might be the interface between your POD and your computer?  :Let's start there and see where it leads.  Also I would recommend inviting some guys from the Variax Future forum.  Specifically AMX and Crusty - they really know there stuff and are very willing to help out.

     

    Take care,

    Neal

     

    aka Merlin FL on this forum

     

    and OcalaMusician on YouTube if you want to hear and see my Variax 700 running through my Vetta in Live and studio settings.

    • amx05462 Power User 3,579 posts since
      Sep 1, 2008
      Currently Being Moderated
      Jul 16, 2009 12:11 PM (in response to MerlinFL)
      Re: Pod XTL sounds too digital when recording?

        thanks  for the   mention to merlin

       

       

                first of all   you cant really go by computer speakers.    if anything  when  listening to your audio  off the computer   get a  real good set of  headphones. computer speakers  are   not  meant to duplicate   the sound  of ant  true amp.

       

                              secondly   if you want to get less of  a  digital sound  you need to get something with an actual tube in it  in my opinion.  what i use is an older  vox tonelab.  just my preferance then  you may want to experement  with  the  actual tube in the   unit. some tubes are warmer than others  you can go to there  web site  and  theres some info there about different tubes in there  pedals.  mines a desk top. t hey also have two   floor models.  they have  just recently come out with a  more compact model with a  volume peddle attatched   i dont  need that as i have  an old  vox  wah  which i  put a crossover  to  use it as a volume or  wah  depending  on what i need at the time   you can get the one i got off  ebay usually  around  100 bucks   .  all kinds of  amp emulations  and effects  built in. i also like it  because   it  does  what  my  vox  ad120  does  but i can carry  it in a small briefcase  when  go to my friends  to jam  . i just hook it up to  the pa

       

       

                                            i can also  emulate  my  twin reverb  with it .

       

                                                                                                                       bottom line is  you may be able to get close  but you really cant  get tube sound  without  a real tube inline somewhere.

       

       

        my personal   amp  emuation  preferences  are   fender  twin  reverb  and  vox  ac30  tb   in that order

       

       

       

           the  guys to get  some real good info   on here are  merlin crusty  and  chris blackwell.  there  all really up  on there stuff.

      • MerlinFL Iknowathingortwo 1,524 posts since
        Jul 17, 2007
        Currently Being Moderated
        Jul 16, 2009 12:39 PM (in response to amx05462)
        Re: Pod XTL sounds too digital when recording?

        amx05462 wrote:

         

          thanks  for the   mention to merlin

         

         

                  first of all   you cant really go by computer speakers.    if anything  when  listening to your audio  off the computer   get a  real good set of  headphones. computer speakers  are   not  meant to duplicate   the sound  of ant  true amp.

         

                                secondly   if you want to get less of  a  digital sound  you need to get something with an actual tube in it  in my opinion.  what i use is an older  vox tonelab.  just my preferance then  you may want to experement  with  the  actual tube in the   unit. some tubes are warmer than others  you can go to there  web site  and  theres some info there about different tubes in there  pedals.  mines a desk top. t hey also have two   floor models.  they have  just recently come out with a  more compact model with a  volume peddle attatched   i dont  need that as i have  an old  vox  wah  which i  put a crossover  to  use it as a volume or  wah  depending  on what i need at the time   you can get the one i got off  ebay usually  around  100 bucks   .  all kinds of  amp emulations  and effects  built in. i also like it  because   it  does  what  my  vox  ad120  does  but i can carry  it in a small briefcase  when  go to my friends  to jam  . i just hook it up to  the pa

         

         

                                              i can also  emulate  my  twin reverb  with it .

         

                                                                                                                         bottom line is  you may be able to get close  but you really cant  get tube sound  without  a real tube inline somewhere.

         

         

          my personal   amp  emuation  preferences  are   fender  twin  reverb  and  vox  ac30  tb   in that order

         

         

         

             the  guys to get  some real good info   on here are  merlin crusty  and  chris blackwell.  there  all really up  on there stuff.

         

        Hi AMX and you're very welcome as I respect your thought as well as the others you mentioned.

         

        With that said - I respectfully have to disagree abit with some of the things you said.  Obviously I have NOT A SINGLE opposite thing to say about any of your advice about actually using tubes to get the true tube sound.  However, I think that to be fair - I have to say that My computer speaker system is as good as any Home stereo 5.1 system.  Those are what I Master all of my recordings with and it is not as cheesy as most cheap computer stereo speakers that ARE indeed horrible. So a little leeway needs to be given based on the speaker system connected to the computer.

         

        The other bit is that I have found that at least regarding my Vetta and many MONTHS of constant tweaking and more tweaking I have most of my patches that sound very "tube-like".  What I've found is most significant is the overall volume players use to set up their patches.  I've seen first hand that most players set up their patches at home in a quiet environment at much lower volumes than they actually perform at.  This in turn causes them to usually put too much high end into a patch or perhaps too much low end because at low volumes all of these things sound differently than at reasonably loud performance volumes.  I've given master classes on just this topic with both solid state and tube amps.  It's always met with the exact same skepticism when I talk about the midrange.  Most usually have some stupid smiley face type of EQ settings and think that is a great sound.  Perhaps for thrash metal or hardcore punk, but after I explain to them that MOST of the guitars range of sound is IN the Midrange, they still look at me funny until I set up a patch at low volume that they all hate.  Then I turn it up to a performance volume and the tone balances out and NOW they are all impressed.

         

        So the point to all of that is that the use of mids in the context of amp models CAN give a very warm "tube-like" sound without ever using real tubes.  If anyone ever wants some of my patches that match what I've said, please just ask and I'll be happy to share them.

         

        Sorry if any of what I just typed is already known and understood well by any readers on here, but some are still unaware of this problem/solution.

        • amx05462 Power User 3,579 posts since
          Sep 1, 2008
          Currently Being Moderated
          Jul 16, 2009 1:06 PM (in response to MerlinFL)
          Re: Pod XTL sounds too digital when recording?

            i couldnt agree with you more merlin accept  im going  under the assumption that you have  a pro setup on your computer  as you  do everything   to the highest  of standards  .  what i was thinking  was exactly that .  but not knowing  what kind of speaker system  warhert  has   i made the  assumption that  it  may  not be  a high end monitor setup which  would tend to take away  from his overall sound  . so thats why i mentioned  headphones as opposed to speakers. one thing with  a good  quality set of  headphones  and i mean the  full ear coverage kind  is  they tend to eliminate any ambient room backround noise  because  the sound is in a captured area between the speaker and your ear.   good point about the  eq too   your  right on the  money as always  about the standard  smiley face setting.  i see that quite often.

           

                 on another  subject    what do you think of the  jimi hendrix  pedal  digitech put out   and the jamvox  setup.  im currently looking into both 

          • MerlinFL Iknowathingortwo 1,524 posts since
            Jul 17, 2007
            Currently Being Moderated
            Jul 16, 2009 2:09 PM (in response to amx05462)
            Re: Pod XTL sounds too digital when recording?

            As always I appreciate you understanding what I'm trying my best to say.  I wish I could do it in less words as Rich R. seems to want everything.  48 years of walking this planet and I still can't simply say "yep" or "nope" to most questions. Oh well - I think it's what happens when you have a full-blooded Italian Mom.  LOL  Good thing none of you guys can see my hand gestures as I'm reading those silly posts that pop up from time to time.  FAGETTABOUTIT Knose What I Means??  !!! 

             

            About the items you mentioned - I honestly am NOT a tech "*****" as I might seem to be.  I honestly NEVER used more than a Morley Wah and a Memory Man Delay for nearly all of my playing.  Even growing up with Jimmy (I NEED A PHASER ON EVERYTHING) Page, I never used to even use one of those.  Just simply plug and play with my LP & a Marshall Plexi 50w w/8x10 Cabinet.  Boy, I sure miss that rig!!

             

            I certainly can check them out if you'd like me to and give you my thoughts??  Let me know, ok?

             

            Take care,

            Neal

            • amx05462 Power User 3,579 posts since
              Sep 1, 2008
              Currently Being Moderated
              Jul 16, 2009 2:26 PM (in response to MerlinFL)
              Re: Pod XTL sounds too digital when recording?

              yes  if you could do that  id apreciate it  as i respect your opinion highly

               

                   by the way   i can get pretty long winded  my self     nothing  wrong  with  saying  what you got to say.    i do the  hand gestures myself  as  my  moms side  is from sicily  and  my dads  side   is portuguese   so  i hardly can say hello  with out  making some kind of hand  gesture

               

                       i just  think rich   is  starting to get  worn down a bit is all. seems like hes  going  24/7 on his  project thats  why ive  cut back on that area  and only make a responce  when i think is necessary.

               

                     you have to admit  there is alot of repeditivity ( i think  thats a  word )  in that  thread.so  that would tend  to make   anyone  try to keep it  short and  fresh.

               

                                         i even thought  just for laughs  to mention  atomic  power  instead of batterys  just  to break the tension.  like with that guitar photo.

               

                                   but he does  need to  realise all this other conversation  about pods etc   has bearing  on the new guitar.  by the  way did you catch my bit   about the headstock logo?

More Like This

  • Retrieving data ...

Bookmarked By (0)