Well I know with Podfarm you can selective to hear the current settings but be recording a dry track so that later you can reamp playback under a separate track armed to record with a different tone.

I would record a take you're happy with ... and then try reamping playback til you find a couple of tones you're happy with.

Then select the first tone to reamp to a track armed for recording the playback panned Left.

Then select the other tone that compliments the previous tone (perhaps thicker or fuller) and reamp playback to a track armed to record panned Right.

Or you could just eq the tracks differently using a vst plug in ..or even nudge one of the tracks like maybe 20-30ms to add a fuller stereo sound or both.

Or add some reverb to one of the tracks or both one with bright and one with a bigger darker reverb ... there's lots of different things to do.

The MP3 seemed to have all the guitars and bass using the same mid frequencies ..the bass should be covering more of the lows and the guitars could probably stay right where they're at.

Reamping allows you to try some different sounds blending them until you find a good mix of two tones and when you're happy you just arm the tracks as previously mentioned to record the tone you liked one at a time.