Jump to content
rwinking

intermittent joystick since update

Recommended Posts

I found that my joystick had become intermittent after upgrading to 2.8. I thought it was a hardware problem but I called the company and they said that this was a known issue with 2.8 and told me to go to 2.81. I did that and the issue is back. Anyone else on this?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When you called them back and told them that you still had the issue, what did they say?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
38 minutes ago, rwinking said:

I found that my joystick had become intermittent after upgrading to 2.8. I thought it was a hardware problem but I called the company and they said that this was a known issue with 2.8 and told me to go to 2.81. I did that and the issue is back. Anyone else on this?

 

Hi,

 

Just when you think that everything is going perfectly,

 

Yes, just encountered this issue this afternoon and I have now reverted to v2.71 and everything works as it should.

 

The reason for my worry was that prior to v2.80, I had sent off my Helix for a repair to the Joystick which had a solder connection that had come adrift. When it returned from repair I installed v2.80 with no problems. This week I installed 2.81 and all was working fine until this emerged today.

 

As the Line 6 service engineers gave me a 3 month warranty on the repair, I needed to verify that this was not a repeat of the hardware problem. It seems that this is down to something in the 2.80 and the 2.81 firmware and all the usual reset procedures didn’t resolve the buggy Joystick.

 

Downgrade to earlier firmware fixes this.

 

Description; of bug:

While using the Joystick to select a block it would function normally in “jog mode”, but when you “press down to click select” It doesn’t always respond. Makes preset creation very difficult using only the Helix hardware.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yep, that is it....if I want to open up a block it takes about ten tries to get it to work Once I get to the choices (I.e. amp, cab, Distortion, etc.) it works fine. I have not called them back yet. I had the problem in 2.8 and he told me that 2.81 would fix it. I would rather not go back to 2.7 but may have to. Like you, I thought something was wrong with the joystick. It was good to hear that it was a software issue at least. Check out my other post about clipping in 4CM. That also started with 2.8 but could just be coincidental.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

OK, I'm confused. I'm on 2.81. I usually use HXEdit to create and mod presets. I guess I hadn't used the joystick for anything other than moving from one block to another to expose parameters since I don't really know when! So I just went over to my floor and tried it - all it would do was move from one block to another, pressing it wouldn't take me to the model list! Then I went to Globals and at the end of the Preferences section there's a Joystick Encoder setting - I never noticed this before. Is this new? It presents a choice between Model and Selection. It was on Selection. I switched it to Model and all was as it should be, same as it ever was. Using the arrows switches blocks, pressing it takes you to the Model list, turning it selects the next Model in the list. Pressing Actions and using the arrows moves the block. IOW, everything works the way it should.

 

Am I misunderstanding the problem?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I’ll for sure try that when I get home. Are you saying that going into global and switching the joy stick encoder from Selection to Model fixed it? That is great if I am getting what you are saying.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, rwinking said:

I’ll for sure try that when I get home. Are you saying that going into global and switching the joy stick encoder from Selection to Model fixed it? That is great if I am getting what you are saying.

 

Maybe. Your problem sounds different. I'm just saying that with that setting on Model, my joystick works the same way it always did.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

... you might find that pressing and releasing the joystick push function quicker makes it act predictably - it seems to ignore 'long' presses since v2.8x, and 'long' isn't all that long either.

 

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I tried quick pushes as well as holding it and it just had a mind of it’s own.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

New Global setting option as of 2.80. 

 

The 2.80 RELEASE NOTES state:

Turn Joystick to Select Blocks

Helix Floor, Helix Rack, Helix LT

Currently, turning the joystick encoder scrolls through available models for the selected block. With 2.80, you can now choose to instead turn the joystick to quickly move across the signal flow.

From the Global Settings > Preferences menu, turn Knob 5 (Joystick Encoder) to choose “Model” or “Selection.”

“Model” remains the default.

SHORTCUT: Pressing and turning the joystick will provide the opposite setting; that is, when set to “Model”, press and turn the joystick to quickly move across the signal qow. When set to “Selection,” press and turn the joystick to scroll through available models for the selected block.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe "joy"stick is not quite the right name for it :-)  Would be happy to see Line6 go to a recessed rotating dial surrounded by four recessed buttons in the next Helix iteration like the one Boss/Roland has used on some of its multi-effects and synths. Not only do I like the action better but it is pretty much flush with chassis so you don't have to worry that a tight fitting case might damage the soldering/assembly and disable the "joy"stick.

 

https://www.roland.com/us/products/gr-55/

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
 
 
 
2 hours ago, MusicLaw said:

From the Global Settings > Preferences menu, turn Knob 5 (Joystick Encoder) to choose “Model” or “Selection.”

“Model” remains the default.

 

To be fair, I think they got the last statement wrong!


When I initially updated to 2.80, I'm 99% certain that my LT was using "Selection", and I had to change it back to "Model".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
10 hours ago, MusicLaw said:

New Global setting option as of 2.80. 

 

The 2.80 RELEASE NOTES state:

 Turn Joystick to Select Blocks

 

Hi,

 

I was well aware of this change before I updated my Firmware. Someone had shown me a video of the fast scroll across the signal flow blocks while my Helix was away for a physical repair to the Joystick. What a novelty, I could hardly wait for mine to come back from the Service Engineer.

 

I had been running through a lot of stuff for the first couple of days after installing 2.81 and didn’t notice any weirdness. Then this not responding to “click, select” came from out of nowhere. Bizarre. Multiple, reboots and resets changed nothing so I thought it could be that the hardware was damaged and regressed to 2.71 to check - all was as it should be. Good - no need to ship it back to the Service Centre.

 

Now I am going to reinstall 2.81 and check out the thing again following the advice given above by MonkeyXT. This time I’ll  try not to be as ham fisted with the encoder.

 

I’ll report back later.

 

 

EDIT:

Update 3 hours later - BTW That's not how long it took, I had to do something else first.

Simple reinstall of v2.81 seem to have squashed the "bug". I specify "BUG" because this phenomena sprang from nowhere. Things had been working just fine for a couple of days then - Joystick encoder malfunction! My main worry was that it was a hardware failure again. I now have it working, as it should, in both modes and I don't think my "Press, Click to Select" technique has been modified in any way. I will see how it works out from here.

 

Extra special thanks to MonkeyXT for the tip. 

Edited by datacommando
Mark this as SOLVED! for me, at least for the time being.
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
11 hours ago, MonkeyXT said:

... you might find that pressing and releasing the joystick push function quicker makes it act predictably - it seems to ignore 'long' presses since v2.8x, and 'long' isn't all that long either.

 

 

Thanks MonkeyXT,

 

See update note above.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, datacommando said:

 

Hi,

 

I was well aware of this change before I updated my Firmware. Someone had shown me a video of the fast scroll across the signal flow blocks while my Helix was away for a physical repair to the Joystick. What a novelty, I could hardly wait for mine to come back from the Service Engineer.

 

I had been running through a lot of stuff for the first couple of days after installing 2.81 and didn’t notice any weirdness. Then this not responding to “click, select” came from out of nowhere. Bizarre. Multiple, reboots and resets changed nothing so I thought it could be that the hardware was damaged and regressed to 2.71 to check - all was as it should be. Good - no need to ship it back to the Service Centre.

 

Now I am going to reinstall 2.81 and check out the thing again following the advice given above by MonkeyXT. This time I’ll  try not to be as ham fisted with the encoder.

 

I’ll report back later.

After a complete restore from Backup I resolved this by powering off, FS10-FS11 "Upgrade to latest format" then going into Global settings and changing the behavior to "Model", use it once, change back to "Selection", use it once, then shutdown and turn on again.  If it appears again I am going to try MonkeyXT's suggestion as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
40 minutes ago, jpdennis said:

After a complete restore from Backup I resolved this by powering off, FS10-FS11 "Upgrade to latest format" then going into Global settings and changing the behavior to "Model", use it once, change back to "Selection", use it once, then shutdown and turn on again.  If it appears again I am going to try MonkeyXT's suggestion as well.

 

Hi,

 

As I noted previously, I spent most of yesterday afternoon going through every reboot/reset combination on the list. Plus I had done the "Upgrade existing presets to latest format" soon after getting the firmware installed and everything had been working perfectly until this Joystick thing manifested itself. The main worry for me was that the malfunction could have been a hardware failure, especially since it had only recently undergone a repair to a solder joint on the Joystick encoder.

 

Once I had regressed to v2.71, I then knew it was not a hardware issue, phew, relief! My next plan of action would have been to re-install the latest firmware and see if the problem persists. So far, luckily it seems to be working fine once more. 

 

MonkeyXT's tip is worth knowing, although I am not certain that my touch on the encoder is any heavier or lighter, I'm just happy it works - for how long, who knows?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 8/8/2019 at 5:22 PM, rd2rk said:

When you called them back and told them that you still had the issue, what did they say?

They said they were well aware of the issue and that updating to 2.8.1 would fix it. It did not....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
33 minutes ago, rwinking said:

They said they were well aware of the issue and that updating to 2.8.1 would fix it. It did not....

 

You should let them know that it didn't fix it. Like I said earlier, I don't now, nor have I ever, had joystick problems, though apparently I'm just lucky? Other than the 2.8.1 update (or could've been 2.8) setting that encoder global to Selection, I've had no problems.

 

Do let us know what they say when you tell them it's not fixed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi, i bought and got a brand Helix 15 days ago. I played a little bit with it just after unboxing. 

Perfect but 2.30 version, so i updated to 2.81 and everything was working fine.

 

Then i tried to program using the joystick. It was working 1 time on 5...

I checked the forum and saw it was a known issue for years and it was a mecanic problem.

 

I call the shop to explain the problem and they asked me to return (2 days old unit...).

 

Today they told me I just had to reset the Helix (what they did) and everything is ok now.

They will send me back my Helix reseted.

 

You think it's ok ?

 

Thanks

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
38 minutes ago, krapo said:

You think it's ok ?

 

Hi,

 

Yes, I think it will be O.K. now.

 

I had that problem back on August 9th, a reinstall and full reset seems to have fixed the issue and since then it is used every day and works perfectly.

 

If it is a hardware problem you can simply have the unit replaced under warranty, but the dealer must be happy with the reset fix.

 

Try it and see how it goes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi, just got back my Helix from the shop today.

 

They told me there was no problem and they just made reset.

 

But I was very desapointed because (after 2 weeks lost) the problem was not fixed...

 

Finally i tried MonkeyXT's recommandation, "pushing the joystick quickly", and it looks ok until now.

 

Thanks

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×