These forums are read only, please use our new forums here.

Main :: POD Farm / POD Studio / TonePort

Can’t choose between POD Studio GX and BackTrack
by elegault2 on 2011-07-22 09:52:39.7040

I’m simply paralyzed by indecision right now and can’t seem to decide which easy recording option to choose.  First, here’s my setup:  GuitarPort with GearBox, plus Spider IV 75 with FBV Shortboard MKII.  What I ultimately want to do is record a live performance to a guitar backing track.  I’ll be using a Flip video camcorder to record the video, and whatever makes sense to record the guitar so that it sounds better than what’s picked up by the Flip camera’s microphone.  Live guitar will be through the Spider so I can use the FBV to switch effects during the song.

For final production, I’ll need to trim the guitar track and the video track and synchronize the timeline for both so that it appears the audio was recorded along with the video.  I’ll also need to mute the video track’s audio (which will be recording the backing track as it plays out of my computer speakers, unless I listen to it with headphones while playing), and splice in the .mp3 of the backing track so that it also sounds better than what would be recorded by the Flip camera.  Obviously Ableton or RiffWorks won’t help with video editing, but I’d need to output the guitar track to .wav for importing into whatever video editing software I decide to use.

Using POD Farm with the GX seems redundant and unnecessary because obviously I’ll be playing through my Spider (that has all the effects I need anyway) with the GX setup post-amp.  Using the BackTrack post-amp sounds handy because I won’t need to use my computer to record, PLUS it’s very useful for just on-the-fly recording.  However, it seems RIffWorks can’t import.wav files recorded with the BackTrack so I can’t do any post edits to the guitar track.  Not sure about Ableton yet.

The BackTrack comes with no software, and while Ableton and RiffWorks are bundled with the GX they are free for download anyway.

Aside from splicing recorded guitar into videos, I anticipate wanting a very easy program for recording riffs, creating songs or jamming along to drum tracks.  Not sure how which hardware fits into this quite yet.  I’d probably prefer to record via the Spider so I can use the FBV, negating the need for GuitarPort or POD Farm.

Any suggestions and insights would be appreciated!  Even just writing this helps me to clarify my priorities, but who knows what I’m missing.

RE: Can’t choose between POD Studio GX and BackTrack
by Line6Don on 2011-08-01 11:23:32.0600

Hey elegault2,

I would recommend the POD Studio GX. In my opinion, it will better benefit you in the long run because you will have a way to record directly onto the computer, which will make it easier then transfer files from the back track. Although that is an option for you, most DAW's do support .wav files, so you could import the audio and edit it.

The FBV will work with POD Farm software, so you will be able to control your digital rig like you do your Spider IV.

Ultimately it comes down, to what works best for you. Either of those products will work great for what you are trying to do.

Re: RE: Can’t choose between POD Studio GX and BackTrack
by elegault2 on 2011-08-02 06:55:28.0950

Thanks Don.  I actually decided on the M-Audio Fast Track - it was a lot cheaper than the UX1 for a product with a Mic-in.  So far everything is great, although I wish my Spider 75 didn't kill the speakers when the Direct Out is used. Should've bought the 150 I guess!

RE: Can’t choose between POD Studio GX and BackTrack
by Line6Don on 2011-08-05 08:48:11.2990

Hey elegault2,

You are very welcome.

The information above may not be current, and you should direct questions to the current forum or review the manual.