Update! So I replaced the PCB that I just had delivered from Full Compass and everything works great now. Easy, proper, $7 fix! The only thing that needs to be done is to solder the 6 wires on. The PCB also comes with the volume/wah switch and is scored to snap off before installing. I didn't install the new switch because the old one worked fine.
saracen22, I will message you to see if I can help you get a new PCB :)