phil_m, can you clear something up for me? I see discussions in FB about what people describe as "thin tone" or overly bright tone due to phantom power, but that doesn't sound right to me. Phantom power can introduce noise, sure, but I don't see how it can gut your tone all on its own. That sounds to me like impedance mismatching, which is something I originally experienced.
For example: My homebrewed IRs were set too loud from my DAW, and my outgoing signal was too hot, going into a mic input from my DI. I put a 20dB pad on it, and it sounded great. I then went back and re-leveled my IRs, and now my maxed signal going into the DI with no pad sounds just fine.
TL:DR- overly hot signal going into the wrong type of input can result in FOH dropping your gain to compensate, which results in a thin tone in IEMs or wedge monitors.
I now set my patches to be generally equitable in volume to an empty patch, and now I have no issues with level or noise.
Edit: for reference, my output is set to instrument level, I have no pad on the Helix guitar input, and our console has phantom power going to all channels. My DI is an ART cheapo DI.